Truck King 2018 pickup review: A new king crowned

The 2018 Canadian Truck King Challenge results
Howard J. Elmer
March 28, 2018
By Howard J. Elmer
This year’s Challenge consisted of mid-size, full-size and HD entries – ten trucks in all – vying for a win in what is now its 11th year. We tested 10 2018 pickup trucks covering the 2500 HD segment. Two midsize and five full-size pickups completed the rest of the 2018 entries. A complete list of scores by model follow, revealing our choice for the winner of the 2018 Canadian Truck King Challenge.

 

The Testing Method
As most readers know the Canadian Truck King Challenge does what we call “real world testing”. Our journalist judges drive the trucks on a prescribed course empty, then with payload and finally towing a trailer on this same route, one after the other, back to back. This year judges drove more than 3,000 kilometers during testing while scoring each truck across 20 different categories. These totals are then averaged across the field of judges and converted to a percentage out of 100.

The HD trucks and the midsize category used our usual Head River, Ont., test loop while half-tons were tested on a new loop in Halton Hills, Ont., using the same method.

Midsize trucks carried a payload of 500 pounds and towed 4,000 pounds. The half-tons hauled payload of 600 pounds and towed 7,000 pounds while the ¾-tons towed 10,000 pounds and used 1,000 pounds for payload.  

The weights we use never exceed those published manufacturer limits.

Fuel Economy
Each year we use electronic data recorders during testing to capture real world fuel economy. An outside company, FleetCarma, collects, and translates the data from each truck giving us a unique fuel economy report.  One that shows not only empty consumption, but also consumption while loaded and while towing. For these 2018 models the study is available at our website, truckking.ca.

2018 Mid-Size Trucks

The midsize segment was particularly interesting this year as both the contenders were specific off-road models. Toyota supplied us with the Tacoma TRD Pro and Chevrolet sent us a ZR2 Colorado diesel. We were fortunate to get these early in the fall, when there was lots of rain and mud. As with all the contenders this year, we shot video matchups which you can view at our YouTube channel. Through our website just look for Truck King TV – links to all the 2018 test videos are listed there.  

Chevrolet Colorado ZR2

  • Engine: 2.8L Duramax diesel
  • Horsepower: 186
  • Torque: 369 foot pounds
  • Transmission: Six-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case, front and rear electric lockers
  • Wheelbase: 128.5 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 5’2”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3:42
  • GVWR: 6,200 lbs
  • Payload limit: 1,100 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 5,000 lbs
  • Special feature: Off-road tires, skidplates, suspension lift, DSSV shocks
  • Base MSRP: $42,215
  • Price as tested: $45,485


Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro

  • Engine: 3.5L V6 Atkinson cycle engine
  • Horsepower: 278
  • Torque: 265 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Six-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case, rear locker
  • Wheelbase: 140.6 inches
  • Cab: Four-door double cab
  • Box: 5’
  • Rear axle ratio: N/A
  • GVWR: 6,000 lbs
  • Payload limit: 1,000 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 6,400 lbs
  • Special feature: All-terrain tires, aluminum skidplates, Fox racing shocks
  • Base MSRP: $53,295
  • Price as tested: $53,295

2018 Half-Ton Trucks
The half-ton segment, which makes up the bulk of the Canadian pickup market, was fully represented in this year’s Challenge. We tested trucks from Ford, Chevrolet, Ram, Toyota and Nissan. Each manufacturer supplied a truck of its own choice. They decided which trim or accessory package to apply; as well as the choice of engine.   

Ford F-150 FX4 Platinum

  • Engine: 5.0L V8
  • Horsepower: 395
  • Torque: 400 foot pounds
  • Transmission: Ten-speed SelectShift automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case electric rear locker
  • Wheelbase: 145 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 5’6”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3:31
  • GVWR: 7,050 lbs
  • Payload limit: 3,270 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 13,200 lbs
  • Special feature: Auto stop/start standard, adaptive cruise with pre-collision
  • Base MSRP: $70,579
  • Price as tested: $78,699


Chevrolet Silverado Z71 1500 LTZ

  • Engine: 5.3L V8 Ecotec3 with cylinder deactivation
  • Horsepower: 355
  • Torque: 383 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Eight-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case;
  • Wheelbase: 143.5 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 5’8”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3:42
  • GVWR: 7,600 lbs
  • Payload limit: 2,120 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 11,700 lbs
  • Special feature: Rancho shocks, underbody shield, hill descent, Wi-Fi
  • Base MSRP: $56,725
  • Price as tested: $65,075


Ram 1500 Limited Tungsten edition Crew 4x4

  • Engine: 5.7L Hemi V8 w/MDS
  • Horsepower: 395
  • Torque: 410 foot pounds
  • Transmission: Eight-speed TorqueFlite automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case, anti-spin rear differential
  • Wheelbase: 140 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 5’7”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3:21
  • GVWR: 6,900 lbs
  • Payload limit: 1,388 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 7,970 lbs
  • Special feature: Four-corner air suspension, RamBox  
  • Base MSRP: $63,895
  • Price as tested: $74,550


4x4 Toyota Tundra DBL Cab LTD

  • Engine: 5.7L i-Force V8
  • Horsepower: 381
  • Torque: 401 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Six-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD, two-speed transfer case, limited slip differential
  • Wheelbase: 145.7 inches
  • Cab: Four-door double cab
  • Box: 6’5”
  • Rear axle ratio: 4:30
  • GVWR: N/A
  • Payload limit: 1,500 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 9,899 lbs
  • Special feature: 144L fuel tank  
  • Base MSRP: $55,690
  • Price as tested: $55,690


Nissan Titan Pro 4X

  • Engine: 5.6L V8
  • Horsepower: 390
  • Torque: 394 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Seven-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD two-speed transfer case, limited slip differential
  • Wheelbase: 139.8 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 5’7
  • Rear axle ratio: N/A
  • GVWR: 7,300 lbs
  • Payload limit: 1,610 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 9,230 lbs
  • Special feature: Pro 4X off-road package
  • Base MSRP: $63,050
  • Price as tested: $63,050


2018 2500-HD Trucks
Testing of the Big Three HD diesel-powered pickups took place during the first real cold snap in November. The weather was nasty. I remember thinking that for truck testing, in Canada, it was actually appropriate because unlike magazine awards that come out of the deserts of California or Texas, Truck King is homegrown, tattooed red and white and very often frozen.  

2017 Ford F250 FX4 Lariat (there are no changes for 2018)

  • Engine: Power Stroke 6.7L V8 turbo-diesel
  • Horsepower: 440
  • Torque: 925 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: TorqShift, six-speed, SelectShift automatic
  • Drive: 4WD with selectable two-speed transfer case
  • Wheelbase: 159.8 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 6’9”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3.55 with electronic differential locker switch
  • GVWR: 9,900 lbs
  • Payload limit: 3,350 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 17,600 lbs
  • Special feature: FX4 adds off-road tires and underbody protection
  • Base MSRP: $62,249
  • Price as tested: $92,364


Chevrolet Silverado 2500 LTZ Z71

  • Engine: Duramax 6.6L V8 turbo-diesel
  • Horsepower: 445
  • Torque: 910 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Allison six-speed automatic
  • Drive: 4WD with two-speed transfer case with hill descent control
  • Wheelbase: 153.7 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 6’6”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3:73 with auto-lock differential
  • GVWR: 10,000 lbs
  • Payload limit: 2,513 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 13,000 lbs
  • Special feature: Z71 adds off-road tires, skid plates and Ranchero shocks
  • Base MSRP: $ 62,865
  • Price as tested: $ 79,805

Ram 2500 Limited Tungsten Edition

  • Engine: Cummins 6.7L I6 turbo-diesel
  • Horsepower: 370
  • Torque 800 foot-pounds
  • Transmission: Six-speed automatic (Ram still offers a six-speed manual)
  • Drive: 4WD with two-speed transfer case
  • Wheelbase: 149.5 inches
  • Cab: Four-door crew cab
  • Box: 6’4”
  • Rear axle ratio: 3.42 with anti-spin differential
  • GVWR: 9,900 lbs
  • Payload limit: 2,380 lbs
  • Bumper Tow limit: 17,160 lbs
  • Special feature: Auto-leveling rear air suspension
  • Base MSRP: $69,995
  • Price as tested: $92,105


About the winner:  2018 Chevrolet Silverado 2500 LTZ Z71
The winner of this year’s challenge is a truck that has been refined year after year adding technology and improving its diesel engine. It’s now, in the opinion of the judges, the best 2500-series HD hauler on the market. This 2018 version of the Silverado HD came to us equipped with a new generation of the 6.6-liter V8 turbo-diesel. Its been redesigned with a new cylinder block and heads. Its oil and coolant flow capacity has been increased and the turbocharging system is now electronically controlled. Horsepower has increased to 445 and torque now reaches 910 foot-pounds. Ninety percent of both numbers are achieved at just 1,550 RPM.  

A new two-piece oil pan makes the Duramax quieter and also houses an integrated oil cooler with 50 per cent greater capacity than found on the old engine. Of particular interest to Canadians will be the new Duramax cold-weather performance. With microprocessor-controlled glow plugs the engine requires less than three seconds to preheat in temperatures as low as minus 29 C. These new ceramic glow plugs adjust current to each plug based on outside temperature. This new engine continues to be coupled to the Allison 1000 six-speed automatic transmission, which has a stellar reputation.

Also new is a redesigned air intake system, which uses an integrated hood scoop that traps snow, sleet and rain. It drains it away from the breather allowing cool dry air to get to the engine without clogging it up.

But past the mechanical updates, this Chevrolet impresses with the number of electronic driver assist features that make moving loads easier and safer over all. One is a new digital steering assist that improves road handling. A new tire pressure monitor system now includes a tire fill alert.  All full driver alert package includes lane departure warning, forward collision alert, safety alert seat and front and rear park assist. GM’s longtime StabiliTrak stability control system has been updated to include rollover mitigation technology, a tie-in to the trailer sway control and hill start assist.

 Visual help is found in the Chevrolet MyLink with an eight-inch-diagonal touchscreen. Of particular interest is the camera system that broadcasts on this centre-mounted touchscreen (now standard on all models with a cargo box). It shows reversing images that make hooking up easy, whether it’s to the bumper hitch or the in bed’s fifth wheel.  An around–the–truck view assists in parking manoeuvers. While driving, the signals now activate cameras in the mirrors showing images down the side of the truck, highlighting the blind spot. Other improvements include an available gooseneck/fifth-wheel trailering preparation package that includes a spray-in bedliner.  Electronic upgrades include wireless phone-charging, a remote-locking tailgate and 4G LTE Wi-Fi right in the truck.

Thank you and congratulations to all the participants and winners in the 2018 Canadian Truck King Challenge. For more detailed information on all of this year’s entries please visit truckking.ca.



Add comment

All comments are vetted by Canadian Rental Service editorial staff before posting. Comments soliciting business or promoting specific products or services will not be posted. Defamatory or abusive language will result in banning from the site.


Security code
Refresh

Coming Events

Landscape Ontario Congress
January 8-10, 2019
BC Regional Trade Show
January 18-19, 2019
World of Concrete
January 22-25, 2019
Canadian Concrete Expo
February 6-7, 2019

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. To find out more, read our Privacy Policy.